This time it's not worth two cents, since the issue was entirely put to bed
already.  That was what Pierre meant (English not his native tongue) and
apologies were offered all around and everyone is happy now.

So far as having made a decision on where to buy a vent, the string did not
really make the decision much clearer.  if all you need is a vent, Skylight
guy is a bit cheaper, I think.  If you need other parts as well, you'll save
on shipping by using BD.

Karl Wolz
----- Original Message -----
From: "W. Silva" <wsilva@capecod.net>
To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM>
Sent: Saturday, July 22, 2000 6:18 AM
Subject: Skylight Guy or Bus Depot??

> My $0.02 Worth (adjusted for inflation)
>
> I was just searching the Archives for opinions about replacing the Westy
> skylight and came upon an ongoing thread re: The Bus Depot vs. The
Skylight
> Guy (see below)
>
> Seems Ron got a little bent out of shape when he thought Pierre was
> comparing HIS product to the Skylight Guys (since they are apparently the
> same product) seemingly without actually buying two and putting them side
by
> side!  But Ron, do you think that possibly Pierre COULD  be saying..... He
> is unable to compare it with the Bus Depot's product as he doesn't have
one
> to compare it with?..........syntax????  Relax Ron, take a deep breath.
> You're doing just fine!
>
>
> From Pierre LaChance
>
> >> I just changed my skylight about two months ago from Guy...everything
was
> >> fine with me... good service, easy to put on, does not leak etc .
> >> Sorry, cannot compare with Bus depot
>
> From Ron,
> >I have to laugh when I see a post like the latter (above). It's a good
> >example of how you can't necessarily believe everything you read on the
> >internet. Unless the person who posted it ordered two - one from me and
one
> >from the Skylight Guy - how could he possibly know how the two compare?
He
> >can only comment on the one that he has. And if he HAD ordered one from
> >each of us, he'd have discovered, to his surprise, that they are in fact
> one
> >and the same!
>
> At any rate, now we know where to buy our new skylight thanks as usual to
> the List.
>
> John & Wendy
> Cape Cod, MA
>
> '85 Westfalia "S-Cape"
> '98 Passat "The Doo Dah Machine"
>
> CAMPERS ON CAPE COD
> A LiMBO sponsored event
> SEPTEMBER 29 - OCTOBER 1, 2000
>