

| Subject: | Re: Thinking swap? Some CA legality comments |
| From: | Mark Dorm |
| Date: | Tue, 12 Sep 2000 01:48:10 PDT |
Thanks, think I'll stick with either the wasserbox or a smog legal audi 5 cylinder via Detlev. I'd rather pay than pray. >From: Frank Grunthaner <FrankGRUN@AOL.COM> > >Mark, > >Without the O2 sensor connected the Tiico conversion will never be legal in >CA. With the O2 connection it probably won't be legal unless the imported >is >willing to spend the money on a CARB (California Air Resources Board) >exemption or certification. The latter is possible but will take time >perseverance and testing. In the CA inspector demands documentation about >the >ECU, it won't be certified without help from Bosch and VW. Now If you >bought >the Tiico kit and purchased the Motronics package from a 2000 VW Golf or >Jetta, with the rest of the OBDII sensors and outputs, it could be done on >an >individual basis. As I said before, the problem is that the engine is new >and >therefore has to meet VW 2000 standards. > >A particular problem is the non-crossflow head in that it was never >delivered >in the US for the VW 2000 model year. Also one of the most important >differences in the Tiico kit is the special intake manifold. Strictly >speaking for a commercial exemption or certification the engine/electronic >management/exhaust package would have to undergo EPA emissions >certification. >This says that the importer must have deep pockets, or Bill Gates must >badly >want one, or the importer has a good relationship with one or more US >senators who want to see increased trade with SA. > >To summarize, if I were to buy the Tiico kit, I would buy all but the ECU, >then I would buy a junkyard ECU (Motronic) with the full wiring harness. I >would then graft the two harnesses to support the used ECU. I would then >install the exhaust with the largest CAT I could mount. Then I would begin >the beg and weep cycle with CARB and the inspectors until I got a personal >exemption. Of course I would have data from the smog inspection station >showing just how clean the system was. I would also argue that I got >replacement parts from Tiico, not a complete warranted engine package. > >The point is that personal exemptions are individual possibilities and a >retail license is a full bureaucratic commitment. Importation of parts is a >major loophole which an individual could walk through. A CARB licensed >mechanic could be prosecuted if he represented an imported engine as a sum >of >parts. > >As to future parts availability, this is a difficult call. No critical >internal parts should ever cause a problem, and exhausts are routinely >fabricated. The intake manifold, its connecting rubber/plastic tubing, the >ECU and the motor mounts are probably all unique. Someone better stock some >spares (importer, or the Loyal Order of Tiico-Vanagoneers). Having said >that, >a good mechanic could solve a problem with any of these components. > >Hope this is not done in my typically confusing style. > >Frank Grunthaner _________________________________________________________________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com. Share information about yourself, create your own public profile at http://profiles.msn.com.
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »