

| Subject: | Re: Vanagon crash safety |
| From: | phil stanhope |
| Date: | Mon, 8 Apr 2002 16:14:43 -0700 |
"You can conjecture what a 2-ton front-engine SUV > will do when it > meets a 2-ton Vanagon. One has a 1/2-ton engine in > front of the > passengers. The other has scarce sheet metal. It > doesn't take an > Einstein to figure out the *probable* outcome." This is not always the case, In head-on collisions Subarus are designed so that the engine breaks free and travels under the passenger compartment instead of landing in the drivers lap like big V-8's often do. Having an engine up front can be just as deadly to the driver. V-6 and V-8's are notorious for breaking the engine mounts and catapulting into the drivers seat so it can be a double edged sword indeed. I had a friend in highschool that wrecked his 86' Mustang Gt head on into another car and his Small block 302 V8 landed into his lap crushing his pelvis/legs. Luckily he was not paralized. Phil 84' Westy --- DaveC <voicebox@DNAI.COM> wrote: > > >You don't have to believe in pillows and springs > and socialism to know > >>that the Vanagon is not very safe in a frontal > collision. > > > >The only thing that would be of value is hard data, > and I haven't seen any > >yet. Anything other than that is pure conjecture. > There are many vehicles > >that a Vanagon would run right over the top of, so > there is no way the > >above statement has any merit. > > > >It certainly looks to be unsafe, but then so does a > vanagong going around > >a corner, but in truth, its pretty stable. SUVs > look safe, but we have > >learned that they are not. Looks can be, and > usually are, deceiving. > > > >>It's all about mass. The Vanagon has precious > little where it counts. > > > >Its all about guessing what will happen, but not > really knowing. > > -=-=-=- > > There will never be any new hard data on a > long-discontinued model > such as the Vanagon. So conjecture and model physics > will have to do. > > You can conjecture what a 2-ton front-engine SUV > will do when it > meets a 2-ton Vanagon. One has a 1/2-ton engine in > front of the > passengers. The other has scarce sheet metal. It > doesn't take an > Einstein to figure out the *probable* outcome. > > I like the Vanagon. But I don't delude myself on > it's capability to > protect my body in a worst-case scenario. > > Dave > -- > Dave Carpenter > > Whatever you wish for me, > May you have twice as much. > > "Sometimes I think we're alone in the universe, and > sometimes I think > we're not. In either case the idea is quite > staggering." -- Arthur C. > Clarke __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Yahoo! Tax Center - online filing with TurboTax http://taxes.yahoo.com/
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »