Skip to main content
Gerry | Vanagon
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: Mercedes 5cyl 300TD in vanagon?
From:Westyman
Date:Tue, 17 Dec 2002 09:41:29 -0800

Well, jeez, why are YOU here, if the bloody Toyota is such a FINE machine?
Those famous words, 'It'll blow any *** away'. Get a clue, VW has  wee 1.9
pumpduse that will do 300 lbs/ft AND 30 mpg in the van. Will the Toyoda fit?
I doubt, much less, it isn't available in the USA. Not likely ever, unless
US oil gluttons change their evil ways.

Furthermore, why would anyone in the in their right mind WANT a Toyoda
engine in a VW? They certainly don't have the reliability thing sewed up, as
many might think. Talk to any Toyota technician (one of my best friends is
one). My opinion.

Karl

-----Original Message-----
>Righto! Why all the blather about higher and higher HP little whizbang
>engines, when what a VANAGON needs is high TORQUE, at lower rpm's. Think
>diesel, direct-injected diesels. VW has the best torque-monsters going,

Wrong. Toyota has a THREE-liter TDi four, and has made it since the
early 90s. From the Hiace van and Hilux Surf SSR. It'll blow any VW
TDi away big time. It'll also blow away any VW transmission... Price
secondhand is generally equivalent to $1750-2250US.

>VW is at least thinking of the future and renewable fuel. Gimme 150 hp and
>250+ ft/lbs at 1900 rpm. Subaru, can you match that, while achieving 50 mpg
>(compact car) or 30~35 mpg van? I think not.

I still refuse to believe claims that ANY diesel van can do 30mpg,
and even more, that this is little US gallons!

They are racing diesel cars against gas in Europe. BMW and Gold 2.0
turbodiesels making 400hp... I wonder how reliable these are, and
what modifications they have. I guess they spin to 7000+rpm too.
Hmmm... maybe I should apply these tricks to my diesel Corolla!
--
Andrew Grebneff
165 Evans St, Dunedin 9001, New Zealand
<andrew.grebneff@stonebow.otago.ac.nz>
Seashell, Macintosh, VW/Toyota van nut