OK, I've got to jump in on this one.
I'm a long-time Westy owner who recently bought a 4X4 Element (but kept
both Westys). As a camper, the Element will never equal the comfort or
convenience of the Westy. However, it didn't take much to turn the
Element into a simple camping vehicle. I'll use the Element on long
trips (24 actual MPG) or when I need 4wd (and camping comfort is
secondary). I'll use the Westy on short trips and when comfort and
convenience are my primary concerns.  By the way, at a little over
$19,000 new (including  7+% CA sales tax) I think that the Element is
quite a good value in a 4wd camping vehicle.
OK, now I'll go put on my flame-proof suit :-)
Lee Kouns
87 Westy
88 Westy
04 Honda Element