Skip to main content
Gerry | Vanagon
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: capacitor fix mitigated buck, did not fix
From:John Rodgers
Date:Sun, 16 Jan 2005 18:37:50 -0600

Use to be that Darryl Boehler would reflow the solder in an ECU when he
was buildin up a  a Boehler Dii-tool. He did that to ensure that when
you bought a complete setup from him - the digitool and the ECU - that
the ECU  would work properly. He use to, as I recall, encourage the
purchase of the ECU from him so you would have a good one that he had
checked out, and you would  have the old one as a spare. And everybody
needs a spare ECU.

As for the bucking. My  88 GL did the bucking thing. I found the problem
to be the hose from the crankcase vent to the AFM. That hose had rotted
on the bottom and had a hole in it. It is a problem easy to miss. I
replaced the hose in the parking lot of my FLAPS - no more bucking as I
drove home.

John Rodgers
88 GL Driver

Shawn Wright wrote:

>I had similar symptoms, and the capacitor fix seemd to help a little also. After
>capacitor fix, extra grounds, adjusting AFM wiper arm, etc, my problem was
>eventually cured completely by examing the ECU - I found several cracked solder
>joints. Heated & re-flowed the solder, and all has been great for 2 years now. I don't
>know how common this is, but it is fairly simple to check for. Use standard
>precautions when working with ECU re: static electricity of course. (mine is an '88
>also).
>
>On 16 Jan 2005 at 16:11, Warren Lail <wlail@OU.EDU> wrote:
>
>
>
>>Hi all,
>>
>>Maggie and I made a safe and fun trip to New Mexico (1200 miles roundtrip) and
>>Bill Bones performed well, sort of...
>>
>>The dreaded bucking syndrome began so I stopped and soldered in a 15 volt 22
>>microfarrad tantalum capacitor that I got from listmember Tom Miller.  I
>>connected the positive side to number 2 and the negative side to number 4.
>>Interestingly, the idle that had always surged, was now stabilized.  The next 50
>>miles were a joy.  No bucking at all.
>>
>>However, after about an hour on the road, just when the bucking normally begins,
>>I got a diluted version of the same thing.  It appears that the capacitor stores
>>energy or something like that, and when the system needs it it is returned (not
>>sure about this).  The result was that instead of a bucking jolt like I normally
>>get, I got a slow loss of power, and then a return surge.  It is as if the
>>capacitor is almost powerful enough to remedy the situation, but not quite.
>>
>>On the return trip, I got behind the bus and smelled the exhaust.  It seemed to
>>have that smell associated with a lean engine.  Not wanting to burn anything up,
>>I disconnected the capacitor.
>>
>>Of course, the original bucking returned, as did the high idle (1800 rpm after
>>coming off the Interstate). The high idle is never a problem around town.  It
>>only occurs after extended driving on the Interstate, and accompanies the
>>bucking behavior.
>>
>>Several questions:
>>
>>1.  Is the capacitor really a fix or just a band-aid?
>>2.  If it is a fix, what did I do wrong?  If a band-aid, what is the real cause
>>and how can it be remedied? 3.  Will a new AFM solve the problem? 4.  Is the
>>factory pigtail a better fix (albeit a more expensive one)?
>>
>>As always,  thanks for your help.
>>
>>Warren Lail
>>88 Westy "Billy Bones"
>>
>>
>>
>
>--
>Shawn Wright
>I.T. Manager
>Shawnigan Lake School
>
>
>
>