Speaking from experience...the GW bag is better at keeping water in than out.

On 7/19/05, Daniel Stevens <dosteven@syr.edu> wrote:
> and FWIW GW also has thier Eurovan roof bag on sale/clearance for $59
> http://tinyurl.com/b2aqb
> it's also plainly stated as "definately not being 100% waterproof".  a
> better deal then the $100 one but not sure if it's sized well for a
> vanagon. L-40" W-12" H-10"
> 
> wrap yer sleeping bags in hefty sacks or use it to keep sun and bugs
> off your folding chairs..
> 
> Still available <
> http://www.thesamba.com/vw/classifieds/detail.php?id=193817 >
> $40-shipped.  USA
> 
> dan in syracuse NY
> 
> >>> "Doug in Calif" <vanagon@astound.net> 07/19/05 11:41 AM >>>
> Dan,
> Go Westy has a pretty trick custom bag for the luggage rack.
> Fits exactly in the area totally weatherproof..
> 
> http://tinyurl.com/d2z2p
> 
> > mail before the end of the weekend.
>