

| Subject: | Re: NVC, really - was RE: Vanagon mentioned on Car Talk today |
| From: | John Bange |
| Date: | Mon, 22 Aug 2005 09:32:50 -0700 |
>...if they said how > hard MIT was and is both to get into and to get through as an undergrad? > Of course they knock the place, it's part of their shtick! Well yeah, they were being humorous about it, but FWIW the "knocking" I read was in their web bios, and they're pretty dismissive about their college educations. I mean, not just joke cracking, but serious handwaving dismissal. > The kids who major in humanities > are those who realized too late that they didn't want to be engineers, but > had friends at MIT by then so they didn't want to transfer. They are really > smart. Oh indeed. I by no means meant to imply that they were dumb. Heck, Tom had his choice between MIT and Harvard! I guess my main point is that a degree from MIT is not necessarily proof that one is (in this case) a mechanical engineering authority. In their case, Ray a degree in general science, and Tom has one in chem engineering. Tom later got an MBA, and a PhD in management from Boston U. Strangely, their bio pages don't ever actually mention how it is that they acquired their auto mechanic skills, and the one shop they opened was some bizarre "fix your own car" place Tom schemed up, which they lost money at for a few years before essentially falling into the Car Talk gig. They're a smart guys, to be sure, and they often give good advice; but they're really just a couple regular joes-- a science teacher and a business administrator-- with many years of amateur auto repair, not degreed automotive/mechanical engineers with professional experience. Take their show for what it is: two entertaining guys dispensing common sense advice about cars. -- John Bange '90 Vanagon "Keine Bange, wir holen die Zange!"
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »