

| Subject: | Re: V8 into Vanagon? |
| From: | Andrew Grebneff |
| Date: | Fri, 3 Feb 2006 13:32:42 +1300 |
>The roots is a decent blower, not my favorite, but perfect for >making lots of low end if you don't have a screwcharger option. Not >sure what you'd imagine a "good" blower to be for an SVX, since a >roots or screwcharger for the SVX run $6200+ for the kit alone... >and since if you went centrifugal you'd be fabbing a custom setup >anyhow, for all the work and money involved you're better off with a >turbo, I was offered a NOS Whipple-made Lysholm for $1580US, WITH intercooler (not that an intercooler is needed with Lysholms, but it couldn't hurt. It would have been custom-fitted. >and a weddle for when you chunk your tranny :) I have a G50 Turbo trans, so not much chance of that in my case... There's a lot of crap flying about regarding superchargers... such as Paxton claiming that theirs is not a turbo and that turbos are not superchargers... and which are best. Exhaust-driven turbos make for good outright power but don't boost at low rpm and indeed, even with sequential setups, can't restricted boost-range are unsuited for aluminum-head diesels (the heads inevitable crack). The exhaust can also be tricky to set-up, is very bulky and heats the engine bay. Roots & Eatons, from what I have been able to discover, both have serious blowby and turbulence problems, and heat the inlet charge considerably. They were designed in the 1800s (!) as foundry furnace blowers, and are FAR from hi-tech. Paxtons are belt-driven turbos, with worse revband problems than exhaust-driven turbos. At least they don't heat the inlet charge much... but that's their ONLY advantage. Lysholms (slang: screw-type or twinscrew), now licensed to Whipple and Eaton to produce, boost right through the rev-range, suffer no blowby or turbulence problems, and produce minimal heating. -- Andrew Grebneff Dunedin New Zealand Fossil preparator <andrew.grebneff@stonebow.otago.ac.nz> Seashell, Macintosh, VW/Toyota van nut HUMANITY: THE ULTIMATE VON NEUMANN MACHINE DEMOCRACY: RULE BY THE LOWEST COMMON DENOMINATOR
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »