On 30 Aug 2006 at 6:46, Frank Condelli <RAlanen@AOL.COM> wrote:

> In a message dated 29/08/2006 5:13:04 P.M. Eastern Standard Time,
> LISTSERV@GERRY.VANAGON.COM writes:
>
> I'm down  in Guatemala right now, and I've been having problems with a
> leaking  skylight -- and during rainy season! Some family came down for a
> visit, so  I ordered a new skylight from GoWesty and had them bring it. I put it
> on,  replacing the weatherstripping and hardware, and it looked great. But now
> it's leaking too!  Anyone else had this problem? It seems like the  new
> weatherstripping isn't quite cutting it -- the fit to the plexiglass  doesn't
> seem to be snug enough.
>
> Any suggestions? Please reply  directly to me, as I'm on the road and can't
> always read through all the  digests.
>
>
>
> Joshua, don't know if there is a problem with your  Go Westy Skylight but
> probably not.    If you look at where the  seal is placed and the gutter trough
> around it leading off to both side of the  roof you will see that the water
> would have to collect there to a depth of a few  inches before it would come up
> over the edge, seal or no seal, highly  unlikely !  So I doubt it's a seal
> problem.  Either the skylight  is cracked or the hardware connection points are
> not sealed or there is a hole,  yes hole, I had a van in here a week or so ago
> that someone had drilled four  holes in that gutter trough around the perimeter
> of the seal edge.

I just replaced my cracked skylight with a GoWesty kit lens and seal last month. I did notice
that it seems like the lens is slightly larger, and therefore doesn't meet the seal as tightly all
the way around. We've only had one bit of rain, but it was heavy driving rain, and no leaks. I
did notice the stock seal I removed was in very good condition, and probably didn't need
replacing, so I kept it just in case... I was careful to use silicone under every fastener when
re-installing, as I suspect that may have been my leak source before (I was never able to pin
it down). So I suspect Frank is right - you may have a leak through a fastener hole. I must
say that I find the stock seal to be a nicer design than the GoWesty bulb style, as the stock
one looks like it would be more impervious to driving rain coming up under the lid and over
the seal.

Shawn Wright
http://members.shaw.ca/vwdiesels
'88 Westy 1.6TD 5 speed
'85 Jetta Diesel 1.6NA