

| Subject: | Re: Blinking coolant level light |
| From: | Mark Drillock |
| Date: | Wed, 6 Sep 2006 21:48:27 -0700 |
In fact, there are 3 revisions of the coolant relay that were fitted to Vanagons from 1983-1991. I have described them in detail here several times. 3 different part numbers. Mark Charles McGehee wrote: > Yes, but when a part is defined as being a defective design, as > opposed to being simply a defective item, it's given a new part > number which may be a variation on the old number -- a suffix of > some sort, for example. In the case of the relay in question I never > ran across any suggestion that there had been a previous > version. The same part number was used in quite a number of other > cars, Jettas, for instance, in addition to all of the Vanagons from > 1981 to 1991. So the "test population" would seem to have been very large. > > Charles > '85 Westy > > At 06:34 PM 9/6/2006, Victor Spinetti wrote: > ............. >> The maker (hereafter referred to as VW) designs the van & figures out >> what >> they need to make it work, in this case a coolant level warning >> light "relay". VW figures out what the "relay" is supposed to do & >> contacts electronics makers to have it built. When the "relays" are made >> they get some sort of testing to see if they will work as originally >> intended. Then they are installed on the vans. Now comes a crucial >> point, suppose that after a while that many vans are returning to the >> dealers with always blinking coolant warning lights. Eventually the >> problem is traced to the "relay" & a new design is created. The >> new "relays" fix the problem, but what happens to all the "old" ones on >> the shelves at parts depts. & warehouses? Ideally they would >> be "recycled" & not used, but what if they get wholesaled out the back >> door? After all some of them worked some of the time. So that less >> expensive part you might have bought could be less than ideal in function >> even if it has an OEM logo & part # on it! > >
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »