

| Subject: | Re: Power output of actual vans? (long) |
| From: | Jim Akiba |
| Date: | Sat, 28 Jul 2007 20:08:03 -0400 |
Jake, you're in the pacific NW? We have a few up in your area now, and a couple more on the way. Jim Akiba On 7/28/07, Jake de Villiers <crescentbeachguitar@gmail.com> wrote: > > I know exactly how you're feeling Robert. I had the same epiphany when I > drove a 2.5 Subie in a MultiVan at SmallCar, and again when I drove Paul > Guzyk's 2.2 Carat Automatic here at home. > > Aye caramba! > > I'd love an opportunity to try a Zetec too. Anyone? > > On 7/28/07, Robert Keezer <warmerwagen@yahoo.com> wrote: > > > > So this is why I say seat-of-the-pants when I > > wrote about my first Zetech Vanagon test drive. > > > > I don't need much in the way of dyno testing to > > make my decision, like most people. > > > > If you go to buy a new car the saleman doesn't > > say "hey , can we toss that on the dyno for you > > today? > > > > No, they say "take it for a test drive". > > > > Robert > > > > 1982 Westfalia > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --- Bob Donalds <donalds1@VERIZON.NET> wrote: > > > > > racers exaggerating HP numbers I cant imagine > > > that > > > when the green flag drops the BS stops > > > > > > I owned and have spent allot of time on both > > > engine and chassis dynos great > > > for tuning BUT most dyno test are FULL throttle > > > and who drives like that > > > besides Brady > > > I also did allot of chassis dyno testing with > > > vanagons inconsistent at best > > > I did have one 84 van with a B Bob 2.1 engine > > > that put out 75 HP at the rear > > > wheels every time I checked it. > > > that became my base line > > > numbers don't mean sh** > > > every dyno is different some even have > > > Hollywood HP numbers > > > > > > to even feel a differance in a vanagon you > > > would need 10 more HP > > > I like an engine that spins without self > > > destructing whats what I do in my > > > engines make it spin up > > > If you change the shift point 1k and the engine > > > can take it you have > > > something more to work with > > > the Z tech shifts a 6500 RPM screw the factory > > > HP numbers > > > whats the throttle responce like > > > whats the shift point > > > and will it stay together > > > > > > Bob Donalds > > > Bosotn Engine > > > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > > > From: "Don Hanson" <dhanson@GORGE.NET> > > > To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM> > > > Sent: Saturday, July 28, 2007 8:05 AM > > > Subject: Power output of actual vans? (long) > > > > > > > > > > Has anyone actually documented the output of > > > the various engine combos in > > > > vans? I ask this with a LOT of experience > > > with boasting car owners, > > > > optimistic aftermarket parts vendors, > > > erroneous factory HP figures, etc. > > > > While involved in racing with the Porsche > > > brand, HP was an often > > > > exaggerated > > > > and misrepresented figure, sometimes stated > > > as 'at the crank' sometimes > > > > "at > > > > the wheels" and with all kinds of different > > > 'correction factors' inserted > > > > before the bottom line. The same motor in > > > the same chassis would produce > > > > varied numbers on different brand dynos, > > > also. > > > > So, when we hear figures for all these > > > motor/combos, what, exactly are we > > > > hearing? Where do the numbers come from? If > > > someone simply quotes what > > > > the > > > > factory said the power figures were, for a > > > particular type motor, brand > > > > new, it may not have much relation to 'that > > > motor' in the van.. > > > > For instance, Porsche, in it's sales > > > verbiage in the '80s, understated > > > > the HP of the 928 motor by a significant > > > amount. Said to have been done > > > > because 911 at that time was the company's > > > designated high performance > > > > model > > > > and they didn't want to confuse their Base, > > > 'The Faithful' (911s are the > > > > only "real" Porsche) by offering a Porsche > > > with more acknowledged hp > > > > than > > > > the 911. And the Dodge Viper's hype gave HP > > > output figures in the 450 hp > > > > range, but they figured it at the crank, not > > > at the wheels.. > > > > So when someone says.."Ha, the X-type > > > conversion motor has 150hp (or > > > > whatever), while the WBX is only 90 or some > > > such, it'd be interesting to > > > > hear where those numbers are coming from. > > > > Aftermarket 'speed-parts'...First thing done > > > on a racecar during engine > > > > development is to do a 'baseline' dyno run, > > > so you can see if what you > > > > modify actually does increase power..My 90GT > > > Porsche 928 motor started > > > > life > > > > with some 285hp (on a Dynojet chassis dyno at > > > sea level) and ended up (so > > > > far) with 587 on the same dyno. But during > > > development, many bulls--t > > > > avenues were followed and proven to be no > > > gain or even a hp loss, again > > > > verified on the dyno. "Seat-O-Pants" > > > impressions are often mistaken, too. > > > > I made modifications that I would have sworn > > > felt like 20-50 more hp, but > > > > sometimes were just noise and wishful > > > thinking, when verified at the dyno, > > > > or with laptimes at a known track. > > > > Dyno sessions aren't too expensive or > > > difficult to complete, especially > > > > since the 'tuner car' market has developed. > > > There are dyno shops around > > > > in > > > > most larger metropolitan areas where you can > > > get onto the roller for a > > > > half > > > > hour and get actual data for a nominal fee. > > > > I'd love to see the curves for the various > > > types of conversion motors, to > > > > actually compare It's too easy to just > > > 'say'.stuff about how a particular > > > > motor works..but the figures would be less > > > subjective, if we had some. > > > > Don Hanson > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ____________________________________________________________________________________Ready > > for the edge of your seat? > > Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. > > http://tv.yahoo.com/ > > > > > > -- > Jake > 1984 Vanagon GL > 1986 Westy Weekender "Dixie" > www.crescentbeachguitar.com >
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »