

| Subject: | Re: Pondering new commuter car (FRIDAY ONLY TOPIC) |
| From: | Jake de Villiers |
| Date: | Fri, 13 Jun 2008 19:51:20 -0700 |
Craig, you're the kid who just graduated from high school right? On Fri, Jun 13, 2008 at 7:44 PM, craig cowan <phishman068@gmail.com> wrote: > We just picked up a Volvo 850 (1997 GLT) with only 20 thousand miles on it. > A real gem! > It manages to pull 33-35mpg on the highway, and is FASSSSTTTTTT. > > However of the list you listed, my money is on the "old" R32. They're not > that old. Last year, the dealership I was working for managed to sell a few > low mileage ones (under 20K miles) for $20K or less. The new ones, are not > the same.... > But the "Old" ones, are just SPECTACULAR. I always say its the fastest > feeling car i've ever jumped into (And i've driven more than my fair share > of exotic super cars). They just feel, ideal. I don't know on the gas > mileage, but thats the car i'd be buying, especially if you needed AWD. I > think it's the best valued sleeper car on the market. > > I recently had a chance to drive some long trips in a few different subaru > models. I must say, i hated them. The engines are great, but the interior > was just rubbish in my mind. I couldn't manage to get comfortable at all, > and everything felt like i was going to break it. > > I do dig some of the volvos on the market, and the BMW 3's are NICE, but > the > bucks could be the problem there. Same with the Benz. > > My reccomendation: > Stop shopping for a new car. > Ya i'm sure i have the least experience of everyone on the list in this > department (quite literally), but "WHY?" Why buy new? "Because i'm the one > breaking it in" or something of that nature.... > Well i'm sorry to tell you, new cars rarely have 0 miles on them. They've > been on test drives, driven around the lot day in and day out by uneducated > highschool kids with muddy shoes, and the value just doesn't make sense! I > have seen first hand that it just makes too much sense to buy a car a few > years old, maybe 3 or 4 years old, with say 30K miles or less. Odds are, it > will cost you LITERALLY half of what it would be new. And it's still "A new > model" vehicle, with low miles..... > I also like to see it from an environmental standpoint. I could go out > tommorow and use my College loans that i loath to someday pay back, and > purchase a 2008 Toyota Prius. I'm not going to go into a long rant about > how > they really "DON'T" Get the 100mpg that people dream of or whatever and are > really only "Slightly" better than a conventional vehicle, but i wont. I'll > state instead the problem with their sales (From an environmental > standpoint). Everyone says "hey, i can save the world if i just trade in > this old Clunker F150 with it's 200K miels, and buy a Prius!". Well lets > pretend for a second that your F150 gets 15mpg combined driving, and the > Prius gets 50 mpg (again, pretend). Keeping the old ford as upposed to > buying the new car means that thats one less car that needs to be > manufactured (Energy costs, Material costs, pollution costs, etc etc etc in > production), and one less car that needs to be shreaded and sent to the > fill > (Waste). So in so many ways, your really killing the environment by buying > that hybrid. I was always told that the most ecologically friendly thing > you > can do is recycle, as in making an existing product work in a new light and > for longer. This applies to automobiles as well. > And ya, you'll save so much money with the fuel improvements of the Prius > over the F150, but how many years and miles do you have to drive it to > justify the $30K you could save, and just put right into the fuel tank? > Give > me $30K in gas, and i won't care what my fuel mileage is....... > > If you need an upgrade, buy "lightly used". Let someone else loose their > money on the New car, and save the planet in the process (though keeping > the > corado would help more.....). > > Just my thoughts. It's friday. Please, let's not hear the terrible Pmails > about how i'm worse than Hitler, my views are wrong, and that young people > just shouldn't talk..... > I'm sick of that. > > Whatever it is you do, you'll do because it's what you wanted to do, not > because of what any one person says. Make your own decision, and try not to > believe the salesmen..... > comparing apples to oranges can be hard sometimes, but the fruit salad > created in the end, sure is delicious. > > -Craig > '85GL > > > On Fri, Jun 13, 2008 at 10:08 PM, Stuart MacMillan <macgroup@comcast.net> > wrote: > > > Kim, > > > > 4 wheel or all wheel drive and good mileage are mutually exclusive. > > Friction is what all cars are working against, and that includes > mechanical > > and air friction. The more mechanical stuff you put power through, the > > lower the gas mileage. > > > > If you really need a 4x4 or AWD, then get it, but expect much lower > > mileage. > > A front wheel drive car, or a rear engine van, is almost as good in most > > road driving situations in snow. > > > > Check out the Scion xB. I have the first generation, and the current > model > > has a bigger engine (with poorer mileage), and it may be the best overall > > car I've ever owned in terms of interior space, performance, reliability, > > and mileage (28-33mpg on regular gas). But, you have to like to quirky > > look! > > > > Stuart > > '97 EVC > > 2006 Scion xB > > 1965 MGB > > And many others, including an '84 Vanagon Westy and a '68 Westy. Both of > > which did great in the snow. > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Vanagon Mailing List [mailto:vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com] On Behalf > Of > > Kim Brennan > > Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 6:00 PM > > To: vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM > > Subject: Pondering new commuter car (FRIDAY ONLY TOPIC) > > > > So, I was cruising back from work in my Corrado (automatic) and > > realized that I probably really should start thinking about a > > different commuter car. My Corrado has been nicked several times (and > > repaired) and some of it's wiring chewed on by animals (and repaired). > > But...15 years and a few things are beginning to add up (vents spew > > out the remains of the foam rubber, cruise control doesn't work, and > > with 80K miles on it, I probably should be getting a timing belt.) > > > > So I decided to browse the new car market a bit. What I want is a > > sporty looking little car, preferably with 4 wheel drive, manual that > > gets decent gas mileage (my Corrado get about 22mpg, though I've > > gotten as much as 30 mpg on flat terrain (MD Eastern Shore). So > > something between 24-30+ mpg would be what I'm shooting for. Manual by > > preference, but auto tolerable. All for $30K. (Dream on....) > > > > Jag X-Type would have been nice, but they discontinued it. > > > > The VW Eos is intriguing, but the looks (inside and out) aren't quite > > right, plus I'm not sure you can get 4wd with it. > > The VW R32, I can't get over the revised looks (which I hate). I took > > me a while to like the Golf 4, but this new style is just plain ugly > > in my opinion. > > > > Volvo C70 is similar (hardtop convertible) > > > > Audi A4/S4/RS4. Pricey. and the fuel economy is pretty bad. The TT's > > styling leaves me wanting more. > > > > Lotus Elise/Exige. Snifty, but no 4wd (and even more pricey). > > > > Subaru WRX STI. Hmm, revised looks I like. 4 door with a fairly roomy > > rear seat. Subaru has improved their interiors a lot since I last > > looked. But the fuel economy isn't up to snuff (23 hwy on the > > 2.5turbo). Might have to consider one of the lesser WRX models, though > > I like the styling on the STI better. > > > > Mitsu Lancer Evolution. Even poorer fuel economy > > > > Looks like the Mazdaspeed isn't offered with 4wd in the U.S. of A. > > > > BMW 328xi BMW had lovely styling in the 90s. They must have hired a > > lot of ex-Japanese auto-stylers in recent years. Not pretty. They also > > get you on all the lovely add-on packages, otherwise the base models > > are fairly affordable ($35K). Unfortunately there is no 135 model with > > all wheel drive. > > > > Mercedes C300 4matic. Again, base model (black paint/black non-leather > > interior) is only $35K. Everything else starts upping the price tag, > > sigh. > > > > Porsche Carrera 4? Way too expensive. > > > > Mini? Isn't my idea of sporty > > > -- Jake 1984 Vanagon GL 1986 Westy Weekender "Dixie" Crescent Beach, BC www.crescentbeachguitar.com http://subyjake.googlepages.com/mydixiedarlin%27
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »