

| Subject: | Re: Vanagon List Moderator |
| From: | neil N |
| Date: | Wed, 14 Jan 2009 13:22:17 -0800 |
Hang on. Well "spoken", has a sense of humour AND knows some Latin? How about David B as moderator? :) Neil On Wed, Jan 14, 2009 at 11:42 AM, David Beierl <dbeierl@attglobal.net> wrote: > Hey, Ben -- I didn't know you had masochistic tendencies. <g> > > At 04:16 AM 1/14/2009, BenT Syncro wrote: >> >> I volunteered to try my hand as List moderator. ..... >> I believe that in order for the List to continue to survive as a >> true community, some sort of moderation needs to be put in effect. > > Yes, so do I. And I think that this list functioned very well under > Coyote and under Tom C, who both I think followed Lu-Tze's > observation that ruling a large kingdom is like cooking a small > fish. They were both moderate on content, clear in their decisions*, > kept their own rules. Both had clear "ownership" of the list, and it > was clear that their decisions were not appealable to a higher > authority. Further, and IMO this is significant, in my recollection > neither one lectured the membership. They made and announced rulings > when they deemed it necessary, they didn't publicly discuss said rulings. > > *During *my* tenure on the list -- I came in during Coyote's rule -- > two people were expelled. One case was clearcut -- overt Naziism put > forward by a technical expert who I suspect had direct experience of > what he spoke. He spoke up, the hammer fell, and he was > history. The other to my mind was arguable (I forget the grounds > exactly, being a general PIA over a long time comes to mind), and > personally I would have suspended the offender for six months rather > than a lifetime ban. But the judgment was clear, and clearly within > the authority of the moderator. > >> That would be an [in]excusable shame. > > Hear, hear! > >> As far as I can recall, the choice for moderator has always >> been decided by the people with the hardware (for the listserver). Now >> it's >> apparently a totally different deal. Jim was able to moderate remotely. >> The >> equipment is still at TomC's place and I think there is still some >> connection to Coyote's vanagon.com site. > > *Rem acu tetegisti!*
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »