

| Subject: | Re: VW bus and beetle on Yahoo's 10 deadlies car list. Any thruth? Bay vs. Vanagon |
| From: | Andrew Grebneff |
| Date: | Mon, 16 Feb 2009 23:03:51 +1200 |
> The rear swing axle designs of the beetle, bay > and splittie all offered problems for the inexperienced or ignorant driver Bays were not swingaxle, used the basic Split suspendion and had an added semitrailing arm. A Split with an added front swaybar, or a later Split, handled very competently, with none of the rear-jacking and gross (but not unsafe) oversteerr of the swaybarless 50s examples. Those 50s vand would hovever handle very well with a decent load in the back if the tprsionbars were adjusted to bring the rear-wheel camber unloaded to zero. > The high > center of gravity in the bay and design exaggerated the roll under rear tire The Bay was a more than competent handler, even on basic radials, and I had real fun on twisty backroads, hitting 130kmh-plus on the short straights and slowing only minimally for corners. It was a sporty vehicle and the center of balance was not high. At 140kmh there was slight looseness in the steering, but nothing serious. > The splitty couldn't go fast enough in stock form to be rollover > prone, so safety was achieved through moderate performance. With a 1600 added to the split-case trans, my 57 Split panelvan could hit an easy 130kmh and was stable. Adjusting the rear camber helped reduce the spectacular antics on hard cornering, and as I say, a load kept the body cornering flat and she could, like a Bay, whix through the twisties. > As noted by Martin (Poppie?) Jagersand, the T3 or vanagon is actually a very > safe design for a forward control vehicle as demonstrated in the technical > paper on the safety design of the Vanagon in the files I have alluded to > previously on Alistair's site. The T3 is supposed to handle extremely well. My only experience with this was in the 4 months I had my Caravelle GL before its 5-speed failed. What I found was pig-understeer, certiainly not what I'd read about! Tossing the iron V6 and fitting the Porsche six hopefully will cure this unpleasant trait, and the Whiteline swaybars front & rear with Konis snd low-profile 18" tires should make it a winner... wish I could take it out arounf the Nuremburgring... -- Andrew Grebneff Dunedin, New Zealand Fossil preparator Mollusc, Toyota & VW van nut <goose1047@gmail.com>
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »