

| Subject: | Re: California catalytic converter needed |
| From: | Roland |
| Date: | Fri, 2 Oct 2009 12:51:04 -0700 |
"I'm selling my beloved Syncro, only to out of state buyers, or moving out of this insane dysfunctional state." Oops, sorry, just an idle threat, luckily it is Friday :). I already bought one of the "regular" CATs from Van Cafe, $145.00. (but just got notice they are on special this month for $130.00) and some sparkin' plugs. Sitting in the garage, should get to it tomorrow. Gonna try that, and maybe also some HEET; there was a report here on the list a couple of weeks ago that HEET will blow it all out or something like that -- gotta study that approach more before I try it. Roland On Fri, Oct 2, 2009 at 12:42 PM, Roland <syncronicity1@gmail.com> wrote: > Dug, > > BTDT: I did apply to for the CAP program (Customer Assistance Program) and > got approved. This means that CA will pay something like $500 of repairs > after I pay the first $100. This only works at one of the approved smog > repair facilities, you have to select one from the list they send with the > approval package. Well... no joy. The bill there was another $163.80. All > they did was debug; found that one cylinder was lower in compression than > the others, so they would do no further repairs. They had no metric on what > compression is too low, just a judgement call on their part. Now, I told > them that the CAT was bad and that was my requested service from them. But > of course how could they possibly have done what the customer requests!!! > No, the shop does what they want, and the customer pays. It was one of > those shops where, when I dropped it off, I gave them as much information as > possible to help, and they always reply with "we'll take a look at it". > > Instead they gave me an estimate of $2,266.72 to do a valve job. Evidently > the CA law is that they can do no repairs unless the car is in "fuel > control", and their interpretation was they have to do a valve job to get it > in fuel control. They refused to put on one of these handy-dandy new super > CATs unless the car is in fuel control. Of course I could have spent the > $2,266.72, but that was just a first step, then they probably would have > found other stuff including a new CAT for $500.00 So I blew my CAP > assistance opportunity on paying them $100.00 while the state covered the > $63.80. > > I'm selling my beloved Syncro, only to out of state buyers, or moving out > of this insane dysfunctional state. > > Roland > > On Fri, Oct 2, 2009 at 12:02 PM, Dug Smith <dug@dugbert.com> wrote: > >> Hi Roland, >> >> Yup, that's the one I saw, but here: >> >> http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=390090571235&viewitem=&sspagename=STRK%3AMEWAX%3AIT >> >> The thing is, you have to cut and weld it in :o( >> >> I'm tempted to use the BAR "they pay to help fix it" process. As a matter >> of interest, what were your readings? I've had it suggested that it could >> be a inlet / exhaust leak somewhere, too. A friend suggested just running a >> bunch of ethanol in the gas to get it to burn so hot that everything >> passes... >> >> ------------------------------ >> *From:* Roland [mailto:syncronicity1@gmail.com] >> *Sent:* Friday, October 02, 2009 10:23 AM >> *To:* Dug Smith >> *Subject:* Re: California catalytic converter needed >> >> Here is one that I found, since I am still struggling with the same >> problem: >> >> >> http://www.car-sound.com/02product/displayuniversal01.asp?catalogid=61597&universal=39034 >> $390.16 >> >> or start with the products page, then select the vehicle/year, be sure to >> select "Volkswagen Truck" from the one drop down. >> http://www.car-sound.com/02product/shopdisplayproducts.asp >> This list actually shows 3 cats associated with the Vanagon (at least for >> the 1989 like mine). >> >> Unfortunately this subject goes back to early August when I was doing the >> learning and research on the subject, so I can't recall exactly how I found >> this one. >> >> I speaking with smog shops (and others) evidently there are now 3 >> manufacturers that make the newly acceptable cat, seems I have a vague >> memory that perhaps the CA smog web site lists them, or something like >> that. There are also discussions on this subject over on thesamba. >> >> I can find nobody who understands the new CA BAR rules. Evidently there >> is no information about why the old OEM model CAT is no longer acceptable, >> or why it's performance is not as good as these new ones that are required. >> Keep in mind that these are rules for the certified SMOG repair shops, there >> is nothing that prevents you from installing an old style CAT (for ways less >> $) and then seeing if it will pass. The SMOG testers don't know the >> details, they'll just look for a CAT being present. >> >> In my case I've already dumped $500.00 into the subject, with no joy. >> Everything runs just fine, all is well, but the government insists on >> sucking money out of us! But one shop did a before and after test of the >> cat, using that little tap port, and stated that mine was bad. So that is >> the path I am now going down. >> >> Roland >> >> >> On Thu, Oct 1, 2009 at 3:02 PM, Dug Smith <dug@dugbert.com> wrote: >> >>> So, I took my '85 for its smog test, and it failed: >>> >>> 15mph 14.1%CO2 0.3%O2 108HC 0.56%CO 2656NOx >>> 25mph 14.4%CO2 0.1%O2 54HC 0.35%CO 1111NOx >>> >>> The problem being the NOx at 15mph - 2656PPM where 1085 is allowed (at >>> 25mph, 1120 is allowed, so I'm close on that, too). I'm told that this >>> is >>> probably a catalytic converter problem, and it's likely that my 11,000 >>> mile, >>> 3 year old Emico is dead. >>> >>> I've started looking around for a cat, but it's hard to find one for >>> California, as they have the new laws about them that came into effect >>> 1/1. >>> >>> >>> Any suggestions? I'm tempted to get a Magnaflow that needs to be welded >>> in >>> where the old one was... Does anybody have any experience with these? >>> Does >>> it even follow that the problem is definitely the catalytic converter? I >>> understand the engine mechanics, but the emissions stuff is all Klingon >>> to >>> me... >>> >>> toodle pip, >>> -- >>> Dug Smith | Terry Pratchett: It's almost >>> (mailto:dug@dugbert.com) | impossible to ride a rock and roll >>> (http://www.dugbert.com) | motorbike and stay on for three verses. >>> >> >> >
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »