Skip to main content
Gerry | Vanagon
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: California catalytic converter needed
From:Roland
Date:Fri, 2 Oct 2009 10:23:59 -0700

Here is one that I found, since I am still struggling with the same problem:

http://www.car-sound.com/02product/displayuniversal01.asp?catalogid=61597&universal=39034
$390.16

or start with the products page, then select the vehicle/year, be sure to
select "Volkswagen Truck" from the one drop down.
http://www.car-sound.com/02product/shopdisplayproducts.asp
This list actually shows 3 cats associated with the Vanagon (at least for
the 1989 like mine).

Unfortunately this subject goes back to early August when I was doing the
learning and research on the subject, so I can't recall exactly how I found
this one.

I speaking with smog shops (and others) evidently there are now 3
manufacturers that make the newly acceptable cat, seems I have a vague
memory that perhaps the CA smog web site lists them, or something like
that.  There are also discussions on this subject over on thesamba.

I can find nobody who understands the new CA BAR rules.  Evidently there is
no information about why the old OEM model CAT is no longer acceptable, or
why it's performance is not as good as these new ones that are required.
Keep in mind that these are rules for the certified SMOG repair shops, there
is nothing that prevents you from installing an old style CAT (for ways less
$) and then seeing if it will pass.  The SMOG testers don't know the
details, they'll just look for a CAT being present.

In my case I've already dumped $500.00 into the subject, with no joy.
Everything runs just fine, all is well, but the government insists on
sucking money out of us!  But one shop did a before and after test of the
cat, using that little tap port, and stated that mine was bad.  So that is
the path I am now going down.

Roland

On Thu, Oct 1, 2009 at 3:02 PM, Dug Smith <dug@dugbert.com> wrote:

> So, I took my '85 for its smog test, and it failed:
>
> 15mph  14.1%CO2 0.3%O2 108HC 0.56%CO 2656NOx
> 25mph  14.4%CO2 0.1%O2  54HC 0.35%CO 1111NOx
>
> The problem being the NOx at 15mph - 2656PPM where 1085 is allowed (at
> 25mph, 1120 is allowed, so I'm close on that, too).  I'm told that this is
> probably a catalytic converter problem, and it's likely that my 11,000
> mile,
> 3 year old Emico is dead.
>
> I've started looking around for a cat, but it's hard to find one for
> California, as they have the new laws about them that came into effect 1/1.
>
>
> Any suggestions?  I'm tempted to get a Magnaflow that needs to be welded in
> where the old one was... Does anybody have any experience with these?  Does
> it even follow that the problem is definitely the catalytic converter?  I
> understand the engine mechanics, but the emissions stuff is all Klingon to
> me...
>
> toodle pip,
> --
>       Dug Smith         | Terry Pratchett: It's almost
> (mailto:dug@dugbert.com) |  impossible to ride a rock and roll
> (http://www.dugbert.com) |  motorbike and stay on for three verses.
>