

| Subject: | Re: Friday topic: MP3s in a vanagon? |
| From: | Max Wellhouse |
| Date: | Sat, 27 Feb 2010 22:12:15 -0600 |
The digital Klipsch speakers these days don't hold a candle to the warm sound of the corner horns from the 60's and 70's. I must admit that Klipsch has a $200+ pair of ear buds on the market. Wonder what they sound like? For now, I'll have to suffer with the Bose noise cancelling headphones I found at a yard sale with the Bose CD player for a whopping $30. Must've been a divorce involved in that sale somehow!! DM&FS At 02:54 PM 2/27/2010, Al Knoll wrote: >The amount of music storage provided on a CD is dependent upon the bitrate >at which the particular track was recorded. The higher the bit rate the >larger the file size. WMA is arguably better at compression without >sacrificing quality than MP3. Perhaps not at a 2:1 ratio, but still >better. I presume modern decks and head units can read WMA. Mine can't >but that makes no difference to me. (see actuarial comments below) > >A test you can try to see if it makes a difference is to choose a difficult >piece (big dynamic range, complex sounds) and rip it in several increasing >bit rates. Check the file sizes just for fun then listen critically to the >compressed files on as good an audio system as you have. If you intend to >use it mainly in your van, use the system in your van, try it stopped and >silent and try it while traveling. Only your perception will be valid as to >what level of accuracy is acceptable. Keep the media as a test media for >verifying future upgrades. You may discover that your 23yr old hearing is >overwhelmed by your 23yr old bus noise ambiance under way and even a 96kb/s >is fine. For those ghostly silent moonlight nights at China Spring where >the only interruption is the call of the occasional poorwill or coyote, >better stuff may be required. To know for certain you must test it and >remember the results. > >The overall effect is limited by the quality of the weakest link in the >system, perhaps those original cherman vanagon 3.5" speakers. (horrid). >One of the better solutions is a set of wired headphones of extremely high >quality, you get the full effect of whatever it may be without annoying >either the poorwill or the coyote or Rocket J who may be camped nearby. > >Or in some of our cases, the actuarial audio falloff makes our choices a bit >simpler. > >My grandfather had full hearing loss in his left ear, from a close encounter >in the trenches during the great war. He had the most magnificent Hi-Fi I >had ever heard, monaural but nice. One Klipshorn and a McIntosh amplifier >an AR Turntable and other bits of finery. Worked just fine for him at the >time and Caruso, Ima Sumac, Sir Georg Solti, Pavarotti, and others of that >ilk. One of my favorites was early Les Paul of which he had a small >collection. De gustibus non disputandum est. > >But do test to see what level of overkill your finances can afford. Let us >know so we may be enlightened and pursue the shining path towards audio >satisfaction as our diminshing vanagon resources permit. > >Pensionerd. (sounds OK to me) > >On Sat, Feb 27, 2010 at 11:56 AM, PB <pbrattan@gmail.com> wrote: > > > Modern CD players will play MP3's as well as WMA's. Approximately 200 > > MP3's > > (counting 3.5 minutes per song) will fit on a CD, but if converted to WMA, > > 400 songs will fit on a single CD. All the music I might possibly want to > > hear in a week will fit on 3-5 EASILY REPLACEABLE CD's, so I don't have to > > lug around 120 to 200 CD's, or keep switching CD's to hear other albums. > > I > > will admit to being very ignorant of how to create playlists, but the > > Alpine > > stereo that was already in my Westy when I bought it does allow me to > > navigate to folders, which I can create before I actually burn the CD. I > > have opted to create a folder for each album. There may be a way to create > > a playlist, allowing me to mix songs from various albums, but I have yet to > > learn that. > > > > I prefer to use CD's full of WMA's because I don't have to worry about > > loss, > > theft, or damage from heat in the summer. If anything happens to my 400 > > song CD, all I have to do is just burn another at a cost of approximately > > $.05 to $.10 a CD. I specifically don't want an iPod for use in a vehicle > > because it's less to worry about. > > > > There may be some question as to the sound quality of a WMA, but the > > Vanagon > > is noisy in the first place, so I really don't notice a compromise in > > stereo > > quality. In fact, I don't even notice a compromise at all, no matter where > > I am. (Maybe I've never been taught or don't notice the difference.) > > > > By the way, if you download your iTunes as M4A's, you will not be able to > > play them on a Windows computer without iTunes or a converter. If there is > > a choice, it's better to choose MP3's. They are pretty much universal. > > (WMA's won't play on a Mac or an iPod, unless converted to MP3's or M4A's.) > > > > I tried out another device that accepts secure digital cards and plays > > songs > > through your FM radio. It doesn't work quite as well, as sometimes the FM > > signal weakens or is lost. I'm going to stick with my cheap-o CD's! > > Patti > > 90 Westy Automatic > > ****************** > > On Sat, Feb 27, 2010 at 8:55 AM, Max Wellhouse <dimwittedmoose@cfu.net > > >wrote: > > > > > So what if I want to have high quality reproductions from my old > > > vinyl collection? Do you really think a $90 Chinese-made turntable > > > and cartridge/stylus(and its electronics) is going to faithfully > > > reproduce those sounds? > > > > > > Find me a system that will incorporate my $800(1970's prices) B&O > > > Beogram 4002 turntable with tangental tracking tonearm. There's > > > probably some Thorens tonearm and Ortofon moving coil cartridge folks > > > out there wondering the same thing...... Of course, if the speakers > > > and amplifier are crap, you likely won't hear the difference > > > anyway. Remember, it all starts with the source material. > > > > > > DM&FS, who doesn't mind the ticks and pops, and had a Nakamichi 700 > > > tape deck to get rid of the hiss and loss of hghs.... > > > > > > > > > At 11:15 PM 2/26/2010, neil n wrote: > > > > > >> On Fri, Feb 26, 2010 at 7:14 PM, Loren Busch <starwagen@gmail.com> > > wrote: > > >> ... > > >> > > >> > Google 'rip vinyl' and you will find a bunch of options if you > > >> are loking to > > >> > convert old records (78s, 45s or 33 1/3) to digital formats. Right > > now > > >> > Costco has one full setup complete with turntable for $90 shipped. > > >> > > >> > > >> w/turntable? > > >> > > >> WhaddaDeal! > > >> > > >> I can't recall when I last had a turntable. > > >> > > >> Another project for another day. (though I would really enjoy hearing > > >> my Joni Mitchell, Jaco, Brecker et al double album in my Westy) > > >> > > >> http://www.jacopastorius.com/music/essential/joni_shadowsandlight.asp > > >> > > >> Neil. > > >> > > >> > > >> -- > > >> Neil Nicholson '81 VanaJetta 2.0 "Jaco" > > >> > > >> http://tubaneil.googlepages.com/ > > >> > > >> > > >> > > > http://groups.google.com/group/vanagons-with-vw-inline-4-cylinder-gas-engines > > >> > > > > >
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »