I thought this to be a very strange question from my insurance company.  "Guys, it's the original one that came with the car, you tell me."  (1989)

So I've got a huge crack down the center and need a replacement.  I'll insist on new window rubber (sourcing it from van-cafe this week).  What about the glass though?  Is there an optimal source?  Is it an NLA VW part?  My insurance company suggested I go with safelite autoglass.

Who's got the best glass?