Skip to main content
Gerry | Vanagon
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: Parking brake pressure (was I've had it)
From:Scott Daniel - Turbovans
Date:Sun, 4 Jul 2010 16:10:36 -0700

wow, you had one of those big Citroen ugly vans ...impressive. 
Never worked on one, just know casually about them.  I have worked on hundreds of Citroens, including the SM ...Citroen with Maseratti V-6 . They have about 25 feet of timing chains in them, that engine. 
One was in my local junkyard's scrap heap about a year ago. 'Shattered Dreams' is what I call those ..
once upon a time it ws someone's pride and joy ..all gorgeous and beautiful and fast for the era. 
now it's smashed and dented and ripped apart all over and the 2nd car in a pile of 5. 

I'll have to check out that Burly rear disc kit.
Any idea on parking brake performance ?
and it is really engineered well ?  
.
- Like are brake lines supported by a bracket where line transitions to hose ? 
I wouldn't mention it, but there's a front disc kit where the hose floping flexes the short brake line on the caliper.  In Germany they'd probably impound the car on the spot if they saw that , or almost. 
They'd sure freak out because it has always been required and standard practice that brake lines get supported by a bracket so brake hose flopping doesn't flex and fatique the brake line.
 And the customers don't know stuff like this. They just 'assume' the product is well thought out, when sometimes they are not.  
   Well, they sorta secure the brake hose with a wire tie ...
not quite what I call Autobahn rated.   

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Jake de Villiers 
  To: Scott Daniel - Turbovans 
  Cc: vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com 
  Sent: Sunday, July 04, 2010 3:38 PM
  Subject: Re: Parking brake pressure (was I've had it)

  I'm pretty sure my Citroen H Van had inboard front discs... it was just the ID19 drive line turned around!.

  Burley Motorsports makes a neat and inexpensive kit to mount A4 rear discs on a Vanagon. 

  Dixie's rear discs will NOT be inboard. Anybody who's had to deal with the inboard rear discs on a Jaguar X-KE will be able to tell you why they shouldn't be allowed on street cars! ;)

  Seeya, Jake

  On Sun, Jul 4, 2010 at 2:55 PM, Scott Daniel - Turbovans <scottdaniel@turbovans.com> wrote:

    English invention, disc brakes.
    First mass production application is inboard front disc brakes, 1956 Citroen
    DS-19  I believe.

    and I've worked on Citroen inboard front disc brakes...
    air tunnels lead to them under the radiator. ( feels like a Fridae sorta
    doesn't it ? )
    the calipers
    are flat things on top of the discs....they look like snowshoes even ..
    short flat snowshoes with one end pointy.
    you could adjsut how far down over the disc the caliper road.
    the parking brake cable operate a screw inside the caliper pistons.

    there was a car that went from inboard front disc brakes to normal outboard
    ones.
    The Audi 100LS ...
    first popular Audi in the US ....late 60's early 70's.
    Those cars could wear out their brake pads in as little as 6,000 miles,
    which shocked people.
    Don't know if that was the inboard or outbaord version ..
    but generally ..
    the difficulty in servicing and keeping inboard disc brakes properly cooled,
    is usaully not worth the small gain in reduced unsprung wieght.

    also....running the brake force through axles and CV joints, or u-joints
    ...that should be just for drive...
    and having brakes directly connected to the wheels is inherently more
    practical, easier to work on, and safer I'd even say.
    There have been Formla One rear wheel drive cars with inboard front disc
    brakes ..
    so each front wheel had a driveshaft just to connect the brake to the wheel.
    That didn't last long.

    overall, da brakes belong with the wheels , I'd say.

    hey...I'm coming out with a vanagon rear disc conversion ..
    with two calipers per disc !
    or maybe inboard AND outboard brakes on the same axle ..yeah,  I like that
    idea !

    another nuance....really performanced focused modern cars have the brake
    calipers within the wheel base ...front caliper is towards the rear, rear
    caliper is toward the front.   Just to keep them within the wheelbase.
    Lower polar moment of inertia ya know.  And as low as practical too .

    and of course not turning that energy into something useful...
    as in regen brakes ....conventional brakes work great, but what a shame to
    waste that accumulated energy ( momentum ) into just  heat and brake pad
    dust.

    and finally ...where does all the tire rubber and brake pad dust go ?
    The highways should have mountains, berms, and morraines of tire rubber and
    brake pad dust 20 feet high on the sides of those roads ...where does that
    stuff go ??

    automotive engineering design is quite fascinating I'd say.
    I think someone should do rear engine, front wheel drive ..
    with solid axles with inboard brakes, no, one single large inboard brake.

    and there have been inboard drum brakes a time or two here and there.
    what fun !
    S.

    ----- Original Message -----
    From: "Alistair Bell" <albell@SHAW.CA>
    To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM>

    Sent: Sunday, July 04, 2010 2:20 PM
    Subject: Re: Parking brake pressure (was I've had it)

      grrr....

      re: your earlier post, forget the humvee David, inboard discs have
      been around since the 50's. English engineering (choking on that
      phrase mind you).

      and now you seem to be trying to force division between Angus and
      Alistair. If this was not the day that you celebrate some minor
      victory....

      cherer

      alistair

      On 4-Jul-10, at 1:18 PM, David Beierl wrote:

      At 03:59 PM 7/4/2010 Sunday, Angus Gordon wrote:

        Not to mention the ease of maintenance with disc brakes, reason
        enough in my book to convert every wheel you own.

      So you, ah, foreigners think you can convert me with
      reason?  Pah!  Wogs begin at Calais and it was Not Invented Here! ;-)

      Happy Fourth of July, even though it's not Independence Day.

      Yours,
      David
      ps -- did you know Alistair doesna' care for the pipes?  Just sowing
      a little dissension in the ranks...

  -- 
  Jake 

  1984 Vanagon GL 1.9 WBX 'The Grey Van'
  1986 Westy Weekender/2.5 SOHC Suby 'Dixie'

  Crescent Beach, BC

  www.thebassspa.com
  www.crescentbeachguitar.com
  http://subyjake.googlepages.com/mydixiedarlin%27