

| Subject: | Re: Transmission slippage - help! |
| From: | Scott Daniel - Turbovans |
| Date: | Mon, 13 Sep 2010 15:25:47 -0700 |
cool, and the AllData Do It Yourself subscription is how much a month ? I think the pro shop version is pretty expensive, per month. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Dennis Haynes" <d23haynes57@HOTMAIL.COM> To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM> Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 8:40 PM Subject: Re: Transmission slippage - help! > Another great investment for those that rely on others for work is a > subscription to Alldata Do it Yourself. (Alldatadiy.com) > > They now give most of the same information that shops have access to > including parts prices and labor. For a 2.1L with AC and power steering > the > shop time is 3.1 hours. The book price for the pump is $148. They also > give > the warranty rate which is only 2.2 hour for this job. They also give you > the skill level required. Note the water pump is a "B" task. > > Water Pump > 025121010CX $148.00 Notes > > > Labor Information Skill Level Mfg. Warranty Standard > > Water Pump > > > Replace > B 1.6 2.2 Notes > > With AC > B 2.1 2.9 Notes > > With PS > B 1.8 2.5 Notes > > With AC & PS > B 2.2 3.1 > > Dennis > > -----Original Message----- > From: Scott Daniel - Turbovans [mailto:scottdaniel@turbovans.com] > Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 11:22 PM > To: Dennis Haynes; vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM > Subject: Re: Re: Transmission slippage - help! > > For sure, > generally , having a 20 + year old vanagon as an only car is > .........challenging let's say. > > One fancy place I lived, we used to joke that you needed a reliable > japanese > car for when your german car was in the shop. > Vanagons are a bit like that. > they are wonderful ......and I tell people they need special care and > understanding. > They are not some 80's era toyota you can just drive into the ground, > doing > barely more than oil changes every once in a great while ...they're closer > to the other end of the scale. > > and as mentioned....many parts in them are 'due' if they have not been > done > already by a previous owner. > > at the minimum, if not doing some of the work yourself, you need a > technician and a shop you trust, and have an on-going working relationship > with. And not at 100 per hour either. > Bit of a joke - that would work out to 600 dollar water pump jobs. > They do take possibly 4.5 hours , plus parts and fluids, bleeding etc .. > pushes 500ish ...but if a shop really charged 100 per hour ....it would be > well over that. > > if anyone has the offical shop time on a 2.1 wbxr water pump that would be > interesting to know. > Might be online somewhere. > but that's for newish vehicles that don't have rusted parts and that need > special understanding. > > main point, find someone you trust, and stick with them. > People that will not give a good extra little bit of helpful energy here > and there .. > I generally don't deal with them. There 'should' be things like ...a > loose > > screw tightened here and there, a squaky latch lubed ...like overall > attention to detail. > You find someone like that, that cares and tries as hard as they can .. > stick with them for sure. Somewhat rare too. > > and finding vanagon savvy shops can be tricky , but they're around. > > oh, and buying a used one ..once in a while there is a used car or van > that > belonged to someone who really took care of it, dealt with anything not > right right away. > it's rare ..but that's who you want to buy a van from. Just saw one the > other day .. > one owner for 15 years, huge stack of receipts, and he wasn't even asking > that much for his 86 GL in fine condition with brand new tires, etc. > > on the other hand ..some people will not do anything to a car as long as > it > manages to fire up and go somewhere without breaking down. > that is of course the kind of person you do not want to buy a used car or > van from. > > now ..the trans, what is the plan ? > hey ...at least you have a great resource here ! that'll sure help. > > scott > www.turbovans.com > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Dennis Haynes" <d23haynes57@HOTMAIL.COM> > To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM> > Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 7:39 PM > Subject: Re: Transmission slippage - help! > > >> Please accept my apologies. My response was a bit hard but it was not in >> response to your gender. >> I regularly see folks get these vehicles based on a perception of that >> "great VW' tradition. While these vehicles are great for many reasons, >> getting a 20 year old high mileage vehicle of any nature should not be >> considered for long term, reliable, it has to run every day, easy to keep >> transportation. If you really "Can't have any getting stranded" then you >> may have to re-evaluate having a vehicle like this as your only vehicle. >> The >> reality is that any vehicle even new ones can and do have failures. I >> can >> tell you some stories about my 2004 Diesel Pusher motor home. >> >> Engines and transmissions rarely fail without warning or cause. You are >> getting the warnings. Fluid changes, magic treatments, adjustments etc., >> is >> just denial of the inevitable. Unless you tell a shop differently, most >> will >> only point out things that need to be done immediately and if you are not >> using someone that knows these things intimately you will also get some >> poor >> advice. At some point you may find that the purchase price was just the >> down payment. This will happen quickly if you live in an area with >> $100/hour >> labor rates and retail parts pricing. If something has not been replaced >> in >> the last 5 to 10 years you will at some point have to deal with it. This >> includes heater cores, radiator, brakes including calipers and >> drums/rotors, >> wiring parts, and the suspension. Some of these repairs will require down >> time. >> >> If you have not already done so, one of the best investments you can make >> is >> a towing plan. If you notice most participants on this list do much of >> their >> own work. Get some books, including the Bentley service manual and >> consider >> some other education. Auto mechanics and basic electricity will get you >> through most any situation and some of the night courses can be a lot of >> fun. >> >> And since you are a girl, welcome aboard and let us know when we can >> help. >> >> Dennis! >> >> -----Original Message----- >> From: Vanagon Mailing List [mailto:vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com] On Behalf >> Of >> Annie >> Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 12:05 PM >> To: vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM >> Subject: Re: Transmission slippage - help! >> >> Dennis - >> >> I may be just a girl, but I'm not that dumb. ;-) >> >> Of course I didn't think "all I had to do was just drive it." As I >> mentioned >> in the original post, I bought it in January and had the transmission >> serviced. I actually had more than that done - tuneup, oil change, new >> exhaust, flushed the cooling system, new brakes, new CV joints, new wheel >> bearings all around, new axles in the rear and much, much, much more. >> >> No, I'm not stupid. >> >> *Annie Anderson* Blogger, Designer, Thinker & Mom >> web: annieandersonblog.com email: lsandrsn@gmail.com >> twitter: silverlunace <http://twitter.com/silverlunace> facebook: >> anniesanderson <http://facebook.com/anniesanderson> >> *Blazin' a trail where there is no path.* >> >> On Sun, Sep 12, 2010 at 6:55 AM, Dennis Haynes >> <d23haynes57@hotmail.com>wrote: >> >>> At 25 years and 175,000 miles that tranny owes nobody anything. The >>> symptoms can be a hydraulic problem or the clutches are just plain >>> worn out. You need to get it properly repaired before you burn it up >>> an make it non-rebuildable. Hopefully you didn't buy that vehicle >>> thinking all you had to do was drive it. >>> >>> Dennis >>> >>> -----Original Message----- >>> From: Vanagon Mailing List [mailto:vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com] On >>> Behalf Of Annie >>> Sent: Wednesday, September 08, 2010 2:23 PM >>> To: vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM >>> Subject: Re: Transmission slippage - help! >>> >>> Ok . . . this morning after I took my kids to school, making sure it >>> was good and warm by time I got home, I checked the fluid level again. >>> It was a little below the lower dot so I added some fluid and brought >>> it up to about midway between the dots. >>> >>> I haven't driven yet since I added more fluid but I will check it >>> again after I get home this afternoon from picking up the kids and let >>> you know what happens. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> ~Annie >>> >>> On Tue, Sep 7, 2010 at 9:40 PM, Annie <lsandrsn@gmail.com> wrote: >>> >>> > No, I'm sure it isn't overfull. It's a little below the top mark. I >>> > am always super careful when I put fluids in anywhere to ensure I >>> > don't get too much. >>> > >>> > It's got 174,000 miles on it. But I've only owned it since January. >>> > Had a bunch of work done to it including a complete trans service >>> > back in February/March. From what I can tell, it was very well cared >>> > for in its early life. The guy I bought it from, however, had driven >>> > it pretty >>> hard. >>> > >>> > I will double check it tomorrow and make sure again that it's not >>> > too full just to be even more absolutely sure. I'll let you know >>> > what I find out. If anyone else has any other thoughts in the >>> > meantime, please >>> do >>> share! >>> > >>> > Thanks! >>> > ~Annie >>> > >>> > On Tue, Sep 7, 2010 at 9:18 PM, Scott Daniel - Turbovans < >>> > scottdaniel@turbovans.com> wrote: >>> > >>> >> maybe Daryl will comment. >>> >> >>> >> one things ...make super sure it is not overfull. >>> >> that's like fully warmed up and parked on the level, the AF level >>> >> must not be above the top mark on the dipstick. Hyper important. >>> >> >>> >> re the comment " I just thought >>> >> >>> >> perhaps it was because I'd driven quite a few miles traveling back >>> >> and >>> >>> forth >>> >>> to Seattle and Bellevue " >>> >>> >>> >> >>> >> that by itself will not cause a problem .. >>> >> it should be able to drive tank after thankful after thankful, back >>> >> and forth across the US several times if you ask it to. >>> >> Just 'driving it normally' doesn't make it act up unless something >>> >> is worn or tired. >>> >> >>> >> how many miles on it ? >>> >> be super sure it's not overfull. >>> >> >>> >> Scott >>> >> www.turbovans.com >>> >> >>> >> ----- Original Message ----- From: "Annie" <lsandrsn@GMAIL.COM> >>> >> To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM> >>> >> Sent: Tuesday, September 07, 2010 8:47 PM >>> >> Subject: Transmission slippage - help! >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> Hi, all >>> >>> >>> >>> Seems I'm having some transmission slippage. I've got an '85 GL >>> >>> with an auto trans. I've checked the fluid levels numerous times >>> >>> and it's right where it should be. I did add a little a few weeks >>> >>> ago but it wasn't too low. I haven't noticed any fluid leaking from >> anywhere. >>> >>> >>> >>> The slipping seems to happen shifting from 2nd into drive and then >>> >>> once you come to a stop and the transmission downshifts. Sometimes >>> >>> it's like it doesn't fully disengage or something as it kinda >>> >>> "clunks" once you've stopped and makes the van lurch slightly. I >>> >>> hope what I'm saying makes sense. ;-) >>> >>> >>> >>> It also seems to slip once you've slowed down a little and then go >>> >>> to speed back up again - it's like it doesn't engage again. It >>> >>> started this a few weeks ago but it was very intermittent at the >>> >>> time and I just thought perhaps it was because I'd driven quite a >>> >>> few miles traveling back and forth to Seattle and Bellevue for two >>> >>> weeks every day. (About 130 miles or so per >>> >>> day.) >>> >>> >>> >>> Any thoughts, ideas, suggestions etc would be greatly appreciated. >>> >>> This is my only vehicle right now and the kids just went back to >>> >>> school today. >>> >>> Can't >>> >>> have any getting stranded! >>> >>> >>> >>> Thanks! >>> >>> ~Annie >>> >>> >>> >> >>> >> >>> > >>> >>>
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »