> IMHO, most people are better off with a more modern gas engine vs. diesels strictly from a general drivability & economic point of view. Other factors come into play why people go to oil burners though.;-)

Can you elaborate on why you think gas engine is better for general
drivability and economic point of view.  I'm one of the
"fence-sitters" someone mentioned who has been considering a TDI
conversion for a Westy.  I thought the roughly 15% price difference in
diesel fuel (that I see locally) would be outweighed by the nearly 50%
improvement in MPG.  I agree that the TDI can cost more, but I've seen
prices for 1.8T that seem similar - to compare to a modern gas engine.

As for drivability, I cannot comment, and I certainly have questions
about what it is like.  I've never owned a diesel, nor driven one
myself.  I have to imagine the TDI had to be somewhat driver-friendly
to go into Beetles, Jettas, and Passats.  But, I would be happy to
hear more about your comment on general drivability.

Thanks,
Travis