

| Subject: | Re: No Coolant in Small Tank Behind License Plate-why it goes down after filling the system. |
| From: | Dave Mcneely |
| Date: | Sat, 15 Sep 2012 09:08:45 -0500 |
"Entrained" also means "carried along," as bubbles in a liquid flowing in a flume or pipe may be entrained: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/entrained ---- Dennis Haynes <d23haynes57@HOTMAIL.COM> wrote: > Scott, > It is not normal for the cooling system to require regular top offs. Except > for some evaporation from that tank by the license plate there should be no > loss. If you're losing coolant you have a leak or the pressure cap is not > doing its job. The most likely unseen or unknown leaker are the heater > cores, especially the front one. I would say if you topping more than a few > times a year you have an issue. > > As for water soluble oil I see that as a contaminant and with modern > coolants additional lubricants aren't needed. Coolant also suitable for > Diesel engines do have more wetting agents and eliminate the need of "water > wetter" type products. The latest version of this stuff (Final Charge) is > designed for 5 year 600,000 mile operation. One down side is the reduced > surface tension (wetting capabilities) also make leaks leak faster. These > products are usually sold pre-mixed. Otherwise it is strongly recommended to > use distilled water. Water quality is often more of the problem than the > choice of antifreeze. > > Maybe entrained was not a good choice of words. How about fresh, especially > from the tap or hose after pumped, churned and if from a municipal supply > has added chemicals including corrosive chlorine has some level of dissolved > oxygen in it? > > Point is I was just trying to explain your observation of having to top off > the system after a major refill and I see the same situation. I explain this > to the customer and provide some coolant mix for them to top it off over the > day or two. I also make sure to pressure test the system and cap. I at least > check for hard hoses every time I see a vehicle. > > Dennis > > -----Original Message----- > From: Vanagon Mailing List [mailto:vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com] On Behalf Of > Scott Daniel - Turbovans > Sent: Saturday, September 15, 2012 2:16 AM > To: vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM > Subject: Re: No Coolant in Small Tank Behind License Plate-why it goes down > after filling the system. > > Hi Dennis, > I know you said you are not a writer. > 'entrained' means to put aboard a train - dictionary.com. > > yes..entrapped air in fresh water/coolant. > > lol...'has went' is properly expressed as 'has gone' ..as in 'the trucking > industry has gone that way' for example. > > hmmm. I suppose adding coolant puts entrapped air into a cooling > system... > and that 'could' lead to more corrosion. > So tell me... > if a system uses coolant slightly, for no readily apparent reason .. > like the majority of water-cooled vanagons do .. > what is one supposed to do .........not add coolant ? > > what I find is ............that air gradually works it's way out .. > I find that when a cooling system is opened up .. > it takes up to 6 warm-up cool-down cycles for things to stabilize. > and .. > if one just tops up the pressure bottle at each cool down cycle after > opening the cooling system ..do that several times ...top up there if > there's much of an air space for the first few warm-cool cycles .......that > works just great. > > about oxygen causing more corrosion .. > few people seem to recognize the cleverness and effectiveness of this > method.. > and I have been having excellent results with minimal or No cooling system > corrosion by adding to my coolant mixture a little bit of water soluble oil > ( machinist's cutting oil ) as a water pump lubricant and rust inhibitor. > That flat works Baby ! I've only been doing it about 20 years.. > and it wasn't even my idea, I read it somewhere, a professional automotive > trade magazine perhaps. > > If you are going to entrain, please tell us where you are going ! > scott > www.turbovans.com > > > On 9/14/2012 8:40 PM, Dennis Haynes wrote: > > Fresh water/coolant contains some amount of entrained air. After > > filling the heating of the coolant will drive this air out and at some > > point it will leave the system and be replaced with coolant in a > > properly operating system. Anyone experienced with large > > boiler/industrial heating systems knows about this and the use of > > air/vapor separators. It becomes more obvious in the Vanagon since > > there is so much capacity compared to the size of the expansion/overflow > tanks. > > > > This entrained air/oxygen is why systems that regularly have coolant > > added end up with so much internal corrosion. Every time you add > > coolant water, you add fresh oxygen. This is also one of the > > advantages of long life coolants and why the auto/truck industry has > > went this way. New vehicle, get the air/oxygen out of the coolant and > > let it be. In 5 years/100,000 miles it will need a water pump, hose, > heater core or maybe a head gasket anyway. > > > > Don't believe this works! Ask anyone on this list that owns a house > > with baseboard heat when the last was they changed the plain water in > > their boilers and baseboards? > > > > Dennis > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Vanagon Mailing List [mailto:vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com] On > > Behalf Of Scott Daniel - Turbovans > > Sent: Friday, September 14, 2012 2:56 PM > > To: vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM > > Subject: Re: No Coolant in Small Tank Behind License Plate > > > > one suggestion.. > > fill your license plate bottle with whatever coolant mixture you use. > > > > another is ...in my world, it takes up to 4 warm-up-cool down cycles > > for air to get out, coolant to get in .. > > I 'know' proper bleeding should make that not be so .. > > but it is anyway, in my world. > > > > I would never give someone a van back after touching the cooling > > system in any way until I had seen it go through several warm-up cool down > cycles. > > Period. > > > > re the smell... > > it's always a good idea to smell in the left upper vent every time you > > park the van, as any smells...like coolant, raw gas, or burning oil > > will be readily apparent there. > > At least LOOK around in the engine compartment.. > > there is always some 'residual burn off' affect... > > coolant spilled on exhaust or the engine ....it shouldn't take 'too long' > > though for that effect to go away. > > > > When you have a vanagon worked on ... > > it's not like 'oh, it's fine now, I don't have to think about it' .. > > No ...it's the other way around... > > "It was just worked on ..nothing counts until I see several successful > > sorties go by .. > > AND I've looked at the area worked on ...for tools left there, for > > loose things not tightened ...etc. etc. etc. " > > > > you know the old saying ....sometimes there isn't time to do it really > > right the first time.. > > but there's always time to do it right later. > > > > top up your license plate bottle to the full level line ... > > look around the engine and under the van for any drips . > > and really .... > > the smart thing to do is check the cooling system for a few days after > > having it opened up or coolant changed. > > I always tell people.. > > it is normal that it may pull coolant out of the license plate bottle > > at first ..for a few warm-up cool down cycles.. > > and guess what else.. > > what the shop explains to the customer to empower them to operate > > their van successfully .. > > is MORE IMPORTANT than the work itself ! > > in my world anyway. > > < after all..........someone pays, they expect to get what they paid for. > > There is no excuse for any shop to not produce that.> > > > > Scott > > www.turbovans.com > > > > > > > > On 9/14/2012 9:59 AM, Donna Skarloken wrote: > >> Happy Friday - I just picked up my 87 Syncro last night from a > >> reputable garage where I had the coolant system flushed and replaced. > >> It was late and dark so I didn't check the coolant before I left the > >> garage and had to drive about 25 miles home. All seemed well, except > >> when I parked and shut off the motor I could smell coolant VERY strongly. > >> > >> This morning I was all set to go to work but decided to take a look > >> at the coolant level behind the license plate because that strong > >> coolant smell bothered me and I was unable to check it the night > >> before. I discover NO coolant in the tank behind the license plate. > >> I had to go to work so could not do a further inspection, and it was > still dark out. > >> > >> Any suggestions? > >> > >> I have not had any problem with low level or no coolant in this > >> bottle prior to taking it to the shop to have the coolant flushed. > >> (I left a voicemail for the mechanic; he is quite busy so I am not > >> sure what time today that he will get back to me and of course I am > >> stressed out about this since I spent a whole bunch of money at that > >> shop this week. The shop does specialize in Vanagons, otherwise I > >> would not have > > taken there). > >> Thanks, and have a great Friday and weekend. > >> > >> Donna, 87 Syncro > >> -- David McNeely
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »