

| Subject: | Re: cv, wheel bearings, or both? |
| From: | Zoran Mladen |
| Date: | Thu, 3 Jan 2013 17:40:20 -0700 |
I purchased a Welty with a "bad auto tranny" a few years ago. Turned out to be a catastrophic failure of the cv joint - the cage broke. I suspect it knocked for a long time and then finally gave out. So yes, it can definitely happen... Sent from my iPad On Jan 3, 2013, at 16:44, Mike B <mbucchino@CHARTER.NET> wrote: > Well, one time I had a rear inner CVJ on my '84 Vanagon GL come > loose, which amounted to catastrophic failure while I was driving. a > couple of the CV bolts somehow came loose, and the remaining ones > snapped off flush in the flange. I could not drive any further, so I > put it back together with the 2 good bolts and carefully drove home. > VW's have always amazed me with the ability to still get them home after > some sort of problem. There was very little warning or noise before > that issue happened. This particular van had over 200K miles and had > many repairs completed over a period of several years while I owned and > maintained it. I only sold it when I found the '87 Westy GL that I'm > driving now, to make room in my driveway. I guess you never know... > > Mike B. > > On 1/3/2013 6:17 PM, Craig Cowan wrote: >> I've never heard of a rear cv on a vanagon failing catastrophically enough >> to affect driving. >> Generally they just start to clunk when turning one way. >> >> Yep, 1 wheel drive in snow. GOOD snow tires help alot. >> Otherwise a 2wd vanagon is "ehh" in snow. >> >> The droning could also be a transmission related issue, such as a failing >> Ring/Pinion Gear or Bearing. >> Rule out wheel bearings first and change your transmission fluid if you >> never have. >> >> -Craig >> >> >> On Thu, Jan 3, 2013 at 5:59 PM, Zoran Mladen <zmaninco@yahoo.com> wrote: >> >>> I would agree that the droning is likely a wheel bearing. >>> >>> As far as the one wheel drive...that is correct! These vans...as most >>> cars are...is a one wheel drive vehicle. Whichever rear wheel has the >>> lesser resistance will spin. Hence, if you raise one rear wheel in the >>> air, the van is not going anywhere. >>> >>> Sent from my iPad >>> >>> On Jan 3, 2013, at 15:35, Ed Duntz <eduntz@HOTMAIL.COM> wrote: >>> >>>> As soon as it's not quite so cold out, I'll jack up the van and do a >>> little more investigating, but until then, I pose this question here. This >>> is about my 1984 Vanagon. >>>> I have two symptoms. One is a noise from the rear which I think might >>> best be described as a "droning." I hear it almost all the time that the >>> vehicle is in motion. I haven't really listened for it at low speeds, but I >>> hear it when I'm going about 30 mph, my average speed on my back roads. It >>> is more prominent when cornering to the left. I hear it whether the van is >>> in gear or not, and whether the clutch is in or out. This is what makes me >>> think it may be a wheel bearing. >>>> My second symptom makes me wonder if I have a cv joint issue. I realize >>> that when a cv joint goes, it usually means that the vehicle won't move, as >>> the transmission can't turn one axle if the other has a bad cv. But I was >>> traveling on snow, and I wonder if that allowed the wheels to turn >>> independently and made a difference. I was traveling up a slight incline on >>> snow and the van went up the hill partially sideways, probably at a 30 >>> degree angle. It seemed like one wheel was turning more than the other, and >>> I had to steer accordingly so that the van went up the hill in my lane, but >>> at an angle. There was not significant difference in the rear tires to make >>> me think that had a large impact. >>>> Any thoughts are appreciated. >>>> >>>> Thanks, >>>> Ed
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »