

| Subject: | Re: Deer whistles--do they work? |
| From: | J Stewart |
| Date: | Sun, 8 Sep 2013 16:33:53 +0000 |
One motorcyclist a couple of years ago near me wasn't so lucky, he was killed from hitting a deer on his bike. I know someone too, who had a similar experience as the gentleman in the pick up, but he wasn't as lucky either-it landed on his windshield and he was nearly killed as well. Jeff Stewart ----- Original Message ----- > If only it all happened that way, a guy I know who works second shift > hit > one while riding home on his Harley. He got banged up pretty good, got > lucky! > Velma 82 1.9L AAZ td westy > On Sep 8, 2013 10:05 AM, "JRodgers" <jrodgers113@gmail.com> wrote: > > My carpenter - an old gentleman who lived out in one of Alabama's > > more > > rural counties, - was going home one evening in the fall and decided > > to > > take a short cut he knew - down a dirt road that was a bit more > > logging > > trail than road. The road cut through a hill resulting in a bit of a > > cliff > > right next to the road. His old truck was a rattlety-clunk bit of a > > ride > > and as he drove by, he felt - and heard - a big "whump" but paid no > > heed, > > thinking he had hit something in the road and the truck just groaned > > a bit > > more than usual from the impact. When he got home it was very dark, > > but > > there a light on at the porch, just sufficient for him not see to > > walk to > > the house, but not into his truck bed. He reached in to grab his > > tool box, > > and felt hair! He got out his flashlight, and there he found a dead > > doe - > > which apparently jumped off the embankment as he passed, crashed > > into the > > bed of the truck and broke it's neck. Easy venison that night. > > > > John > > > > On 9/8/2013 9:24 AM, ralph meyermann wrote: > > > >> Hilarious! I think there are too many variables for how they are > >> made,speed > >> of travel and air flow characteristics where they are mounted. I > >> can see > >> how they can work but not 100% sold on. I think the best way is > >> thinning/managing the herd to help prevent such incidents, help > >> prevent > >> the > >> spread of sickness/disease amongst them, confirming my place on the > >> food > >> chain while putting my wit and abilities against these cunning but > >> sometimes stupid animals ,, putting meat in my freezer. My daughter > >> cant > >> seem to get enough venison. Multiple ways are needed to reduce > >> these > >> incidents. My fuel efficient Hyundai was totaled by a doe early > >> this > >> summer, sadly I did not have any implement other than my daughter's > >> softball bat to put it down which I refrained from ( she did not > >> need to > >> see that) and it hobbled off and got away from me before the > >> sheriff came. > >> Velma 82 1.9L AAZ td westy > >> On Sep 8, 2013 6:59 AM, "J Stewart" <fonman4277@comcast.net> wrote: > >> > >> LOL, I've heard that question asked many, many times and I've never > >> heard > >>> found anyone who could give a definitive answer. I've seen cars in > >>> my > >>> area > >>> with 10 of the things mounted across the front bumper. I know > >>> people who > >>> absolutely swear they work because they've never hit a deer with > >>> one on > >>> the > >>> front of their car. But then I drove for 35 years before hitting > >>> my first > >>> deer. My daughter took just six months after getting her license > >>> to hit > >>> one. In my area (Loudoun County, Virginia) I see several each day > >>> that > >>> have > >>> been hit and many, many more that have not. I am very much against > >>> animal > >>> cruelty, but not when it come to these damn things. As a > >>> motorcyclist > >>> they > >>> pose a serious threat to my safety. In many areas the population > >>> of deer > >>> have spiraled out of control, and mine is one of them. I don't > >>> hunt, but > >>> I'm seriously considering it. Jeff Stewart ----- Original Message > >>> ----- > >>> > >>>> On 9/8/2013 12:06 AM, Stuart MacMillan wrote: > >>>> > >>>>> My son hit a deer the first time he borrowed my '84 Westy about > >>>>> 20 > >>>>> years > >>>>> ago. No problem getting the insurance company to fix it back > >>>>> then. I > >>>>> wonder if these "deer whistles" actually work? > >>>>> http://www.gowesty.com/ec_**view_details.php?id=4050<http://www.gowesty.com/ec_view_details.php?id=4050> > >>>>> < > >>>>> > >>>> http://www.gowesty.com/ec_**view_details.php?id=4050&** > >>> category_id=&category_pa<http://www.gowesty.com/ec_view_details.php?id=4050&category_id=&category_pa> > >>> > >>>> rent_id> &category_id=&category_parent_**id= > >>>>> > >>>>> I did run with them for a long time after my son's incident, but > >>>>> I > >>>>> wonder. > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> Stuart > >>>>> > >>>> Steven Wright(comedian) once said he accidentally mounted his > >>>> deer > >>>> whistles backwards on his vehicle and the next day he was driving > >>>> and > >>>> looked in the rear view mirror and he had a heard of deer > >>>> following > >>>> him > >>>> down the road......... > >>>> As to your question, I used them"after the fact" when I hit a > >>>> deer > >>>> with > >>>> my old '79 Breadloaf and never had another encounter. I found a > >>>> pair > >>>> of > >>>> deeer whistles in the bottom of an auction flat a few years ago > >>>> where > >>>> the PO had mounted the whistles on magnetic mounts. Must've been > >>>> some > >>>> time ago since there aren't many metal bumpers out there these > >>>> days..... > >>>> DM&FS > >>>> > >>> > >>> > >>
Have something to add on this topic today? Revive this thread in the forum »