If only one axle is bad is there a need to replace both.

I never had on any other car but thought I ask.

Mechanic feels play on the left one.
 I guess I should order the thing tonight.

No suggestion for regressing it was made by the shop.

T.

On Feb 10, 2014, at 12:34 PM, Jim Felder <jim.felder@GMAIL.COM> wrote:

You can also get a needle at your flaps with a zerk-like fitting that will
snap into your grease gun. Inject that sucker with grease from multiple
points. Also, a brake shoe will create a ruckus, but more of a clunk clunk
clunk that comes and goes than a vibration or a constant noise.

Jim

> On Mon, Feb 10, 2014 at 11:17 AM, Karl Wolz <wolzphoto@q.com> wrote:
>
> Should be able to lube joints from the axle ends of the boots. Snake a
> grease gun in there; squeeze in a few strokes, and massage the boot to work
> grease into the joint. Noise will go away.  Plan on cleaning and relubing
> at your leisure.
>
> Karl Wolz
> Sent from my electronic umbilicus
>
>> On Feb 10, 2014, at 7:20 AM, T Collins <tonycollin@GMAIL.COM> wrote:
>>
>> Im asking for your opinions as to identify a bad CV joint.
>>
>> I had for sometime heard a little clunking back there, to the rear
>> passenger side of the vanagon. That clunking would come and go never bad,
>> or caused vibration or anything, It would appear and then simply vanish.
>>
>> Now this clunking is more of a ruckus since last week. I got stuck on a
>> slope over a sheet of ice. So I spun hard on the axles (or the one) due
> to
>> the sheet of ice. Last Friday coming home I heard the clunk, clunk at
>> highway speed with a particularly bad vibration.
>>
>> Had not driven the vanagon this weekend and on the way to work the clunk,
>> clunk was there as described from Friday.
>>
>> I had not seen any rips on the boots.
>>
>> 1) ANY chance a brake pad could cause the same?
>> 2) Does it sound to you guys that the axle is on the way out?
>> 3) One more think, In manual 85 GL vanagon tin tops are the axles the
> same
>> right and left?
>>
>> All this while it sucks to work on cars outside.
>>
>> Thanks,
>> T.
>