Skip to main content
Gerry | Vanagon
Checking account...
← vanagon.com home · Continue the discussion in the forum
Subject:Re: My First Oil Filter Failure
From:Karl Mullendore
Date:Thu, 20 May 1999 21:58:31 -0400

Mike wrote:

+AD4-    This would seem to indicate that the Fram filter is more free
+AD4-    flowing than the Mahle.  That actually says nothing about either of
+AD4-    the filters effectiveness.  +AD4-

The Fram actually IS freer flowing, as the filtering media is thinner, as
well as having less of it than a Mahle.

 In that case no conclusion can
+AD4- be made about which is a better filter, but it's easy to conclude which is
+AD4- more annoying to use.

HUH??? Which is better? Mahle by a HUGE margin. Have you not read the recent
postings re: Fram filters, or the recent test of all aftermarket filters?

+AD4- On the other hand, the issue may be worn engine parts.

You got it, FRAM +AD0- worn engine parts. Period. I'll stick with Mahle/Knecht
or Mann, thank you. Not worth the worry to save a dollar on a Fram.

Karl